Exact Approximations

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

Funny Depo Quotations

I'm reading a deposition of a treating doctor in one of our cases. Asking him some background questions, he stated that he had given a deposition in a previous case - not as a defendant - but as a treating doctor involved in the plaintiff's care after the "injury." When questioned about how he fitted in, the doctor replied:
"The patient attempted suicide. She was taken to another facility and resuscitated. During the resuscitation, the patient swallowed one of the medical devices, a nasal trumpet. Then, she had subsequent problems."

So the lady tried to kill herself, failed, and swallowed the orange nose piece we've all seen at the dentist (you know, the one that gives you the happy air--laughing gas). Then the lady has the balls to sue the people that kept her alive because her dumbass swallowed a big orange thing.

Question: What would be the measure of damages for a person who had self-determined to end their life? I mean, how can you argue future damages and lost earnings? How can you argue pain and suffering? How could your family argue loss of love and affection if they were going to have to deal with your death anyhow?

I would never, ever, ever, ever, ever take such a case.

Dee-dee-dee.

Labels: ,

2 Comments:

  • Tomorrow my class is doing cross examinations. Think I should end with this question, "You are a cop beater and an asshole."? I think it's perfect.

    By Blogger Arbusto, at 10:42 AM  

  • It's perfect, except for the part where one cannot simultaneously be both a cop-beater and an asshole.

    By Blogger Lex Fori, at 4:32 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home